Colorado Court Says 6 year old Transgender child allowed to use girls restroom

Coy Mathis, 6, stands next to her mother, Kathryn Mathis, and her brother Max duringa press conference at the Colorado Capitol this week

Colorado law protects the right of Coy Mathis, a 6-year-old transgender child, to use the girls’ restroomat her public elementary school.

Administrators at the Fountain-Fort Carson School District 8 should have allowed her to do so.

It’s unfortunate for the sake of the child that the situation has turned into such a spectacle when the law and state rules so plainly spell out the rights of transgender individuals.

The conflict came about when Eagleside Elementary school officials refused to allow Coy, who was born with a boy’s genitalia but identifies as a girl, to use the girls’ bathroom.

School officials required that she use the boys’ restroom, a staff bathroom or one in the nurse’s office.

The girl’s parents, Kathryn and Jeremy Mathis, pulled Coy out of the school and have filed a complaint with the Colorado Civil Rights Division.

Frankly, it doesn’t seem like a tough call. Colorado’s anti-discrimination rules clearly say transgender individuals shall be allowed to use the “gender-segregated facilities that are consistent with their gender identity.”

And from a purely practical standpoint, there should be no issues with a child closing the restroom stall door behind her and using the facilities in private with no one seeing anything.

If there are issues, then we’re talking about misbehavior or a violation of privacy that should be pursued by school officials regardless of whether a student was transgender.

But practical considerations seem to have been lost in the more sensational debate over whether a 6-year-old can identify as a girl.

Gender identity, along with the process of determining it, is a complex issue that varies by individual.

The American Psychological Associationsays this about how people know they are transgender: “Transgender people experience their transgender identity in a variety of ways and may become aware of their transgender identity at any age. Some can trace their transgender identities and feelings back to their earliest memories.”

Are public school officials willing to say that this cute-as-a-button child, wearing a pink barrette and a jumper, does not identify as a girl?

And let’s not forget about compassion in the debate about law and gender identity. In the best of circumstances, transgender individuals have a rough road ahead of them for all kinds of reasons.

It shouldn’t be made more difficult by a public battle over a matter that should be as private and discreet as what someone looks like behind a closed bathroom door.

By The Denver Post Editorial Board

Read more:School wrong on transgender girl – The Denver Post
Read The Denver Post’s Terms of Use of its content:
Follow us:@Denverpost on Twitter|Denverpost on Facebook

Published by CityFella

Moved to the Big Tomata in the nineties from San Francisco. No Suburbs for me with its single colored houses and lawns and the excitement of pulling out my trash can once a week. I'm a CityFella , a part time New Yorker. I'm happiest in the Center City where people the streets and people are alive. I'm still waiting to buy a 34th floor condo somewhere downtown/Midtown with a nightclub. "Hurry I'm old" My politics are somewhere in the middle with a needle that constantly moves. I'm too liberal to be a Republican and too conservative to be a Democrat. Everything interests me . I've come to love Sacratomato, Its a nice town in cheap sensible shoes .

One thought on “Colorado Court Says 6 year old Transgender child allowed to use girls restroom

  1. The headline seems to imply that a court decision has been made, but then you proceed to reiterate the text of the Denver Post editorial with no specific mention of the ruling, the judge’s comments, or even what court made the ruling. I have also been unable to find any documentation of a ruling elsewhere. Are you saying there has been one or not?


Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: